Trang chủInternational FootballManchester United once had the chance to sign Mbappe but missed due to scouting mistake
Manchester United once had the chance to sign Mbappe but missed due to scouting mistake
core_answer: Manchester United missed the chance to sign teenage Kylian Mbappe in 2015 due to a scouting report by Albert Stuivenberg that deemed him not ready. Ryan Giggs later revealed this in an interview, highlighting a systemic recruitment failure at the club.
key_facts: 2015: Giggs and Stuivenberg evaluated Mbappe at Monaco but rejected him.; Mbappe scored 44 goals in 2016-17, then transferred to PSG for €180 million.; Man Utd later paid £80m for Antony and £50m for Martial with poor results.; Mbappe's current market value (Transfermarkt) is €180 million.
source_attribution: Ryan Giggs interview excerpt, analysis by Transfermarkt (May 2025) | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn
related_qa: q: Why did Man Utd miss Mbappe?, a: A scouting report from Albert Stuivenberg claimed Mbappe was too inexperienced for the Premier League, leading United to pass on the transfer.; q: How much is Mbappe worth now?, a: According to Transfermarkt, Mbappe's market value is €180 million, significantly higher than the fee United would have paid in 2015.
According to legendary player Ryan Giggs, Manchester United once had the opportunity to recruit Kylian Mbappe when he was a young talent at Monaco. However, a mistake in the scouting process caused the Red Devils to miss out on the French superstar. The revelation came as Mbappe prepares to receive this year's Ballon d'Or, marking his seventh nomination.
The story dates back to 2026, when Mbappe was only 16 and shining for Monaco. Albert Stuivenberg, then an assistant coach at Man Utd, was tasked with monitoring the young player. But his report undervalued Mbappe's potential, stating he was not ready for the Premier League. Giggs recounted: 'We had a meeting, and the report said he was too raw. Looking back, that was a huge mistake.'
Mbappe later rose to world-class status. He scored 44 goals in the 2026-17 season for Monaco, helping them win Ligue 1 and reach the Champions League semifinals. In 2026, PSG signed Mbappe for €180 million – a record for a teenager. Since then, Mbappe has won 6 Ligue 1 titles, the 2026 World Cup, and multiple top scorer awards.
Man Utd's scouting failure goes beyond Mbappe. Under Sir Alex Ferguson, the club was known for talent discovery – from Eric Cantona to Edwin van der Sar. But post-Ferguson, transfer decisions became chaotic – £80m for Antony, £50m for Martial – none matching expectations. Meanwhile, Mbappe thrived at PSG before moving to Real Madrid on a free transfer in 2026, adding to United's regret.
According to Transfermarkt, Mbappe's market value now stands at €180 million, far more than what United could have paid in 2026. Giggs admitted: 'Seeing Mbappe play now, I wonder what if we had trusted our instincts more than dry reports.' This story serves as a cautionary tale for big clubs: sometimes talent transcends all scouting data.
Cầu thủ liên quan
