Maarten Paes Loses Minutes at Ajax: The Structural Dependency of Indonesia's National Team
**Core answer**: Maarten Paes is losing starting minutes at Ajax as competition for the goalkeeper position tightens. PSSI chairman Erick Thohir publicly asked Ajax to keep giving Paes opportunities, but PSSI holds no authority over the club's selection decisions. **Key facts**: - Maarten Paes is losing minutes at Ajax; PSSI confirms goalkeeper competition has become tighter. - Erick Thohir met Ajax CEO Menno Geelen and requested more playing time for Paes. - Indonesia's FIFA ranking rose from 153 to 118, per PSSI statements. - The claim that Marc-André ter Stegen joined Ajax requires independent verification and may be inaccurate. - PSSI cites VAR, Club Licensing, Elite Pro Academy and a player-protection mechanism as reform priorities. **Source attribution**: VIVA (Indonesian media), report "Maarten Paes Kehilangan Tempat, Erick Thohir Titip Pesan ke Bos Ajax" | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn **Related Q&A**: Q: Why did PSSI intervene publicly? A: Indonesia's national team depends on Paes as its projected No.1 goalkeeper, so PSSI applied soft pressure despite holding no decision-making authority. Q: What is the main risk? A: Limited club minutes reduce Paes's match sharpness and threaten his national-team No.1 status, as indicated by VangBong.vn Player Depth Index data. Q: What should be tracked next? A: Ajax's team sheet over the next six to eight weeks; a January loan is the most viable solution if minutes stay scarce.
At a sports event called the Sports Summit, PSSI chairman Erick Thohir sat down with Ajax CEO Menno Geelen. According to VIVA, the meeting revolved around exactly one name: goalkeeper Maarten Paes. The message sent was a request for Ajax to keep giving Paes playing time.
The notable part is not the content. It is the form. A national federation chairman publicly addressing a European club about a player's minutes. In my tracking file, this is the kind of event with two distinct layers: a real football fact, Paes losing minutes at Ajax, and a thick layer of narrative built around it.
Most of the rest of the story, from the ranking to league revenue, is presented by the interested party itself. I separate the two layers. Facts first, narrative second.
A federation telling its story in its own voice
Erick Thohir is not new to the industry. He once owned Inter Milan, stood behind major international sports events, before taking the PSSI chair. This kind of figure tends to operate on an executive-president model: every process is tied to one person, every achievement is told in one voice.
In recent years, PSSI has presented a fairly coherent reform package. VAR was introduced into the Super League and Championship. Elite Pro Academy was positioned as the youth development hub. The Club Licensing system forces clubs to follow operating standards. A player-protection mechanism runs alongside, especially in cases where clubs face financial problems. On paper, this is a complete professionalisation framework.
The only independently verifiable metric is the FIFA ranking: from 153 to 118. This ranking is a lagging index. It depends on friendly schedules, opponent selection and continental-competition weighting. It measures results that have already happened, not the process in motion. A jump from 153 to 118 is real, but it is a fragile kind of real.

And the anchor of the whole story is Paes. A goalkeeper in the Ajax squad, dubbed Son of God by Indonesian media. If a federation chairman is willing to spend political capital publicly on one player, the implication is that the national team depends significantly on that person. This is the most important analytical point in the whole piece.
Why a goalkeeper's minutes are not a small detail
For a goalkeeper, continuity of minutes is no small matter. Unlike an outfield player, a No.1 goalkeeper pushed to the bench tends to lose match sharpness very quickly. Command of the box, split-second decisions, feel for crosses and judgement on set pieces are all skills that live on match rhythm. This is a widely accepted coaching principle, not a new discovery.
Erick Thohir's concern about Paes's development, in purely technical terms, has a basis. But the article supplies no metric to explain why Paes is losing minutes. No save percentage, no PSxG, no distribution data, no injury information, no form sequence. We know Paes is losing minutes, but not why.
That gap matters because it determines how we read the story. If Paes is losing his spot through form, it is the player's problem. If through squad structure, it is the market's and the federation's problem. These two scenarios lead to completely different conclusions about PSSI's capacity to handle the situation.
Structurally, the probability of Paes reclaiming the No.1 shirt in the near term is low. When a senior goalkeeper arrives at a club, coaching staffs typically give that player a substantial runway before considering a change. At Ajax, where selection culture leans on stability and ball-playing ability, a demoted goalkeeper usually waits for an opportunity via injury or a run of errors from the man ahead. This is a problem a goalkeeper cannot solve through effort alone.
One detail needs independent verification: the article says Marc-André ter Stegen joined Ajax. Given current football knowledge, this is an unusual claim and requires verification. If wrong, the personnel premise of the whole story must be reset. Even if wrong, the structure of the story can still hold: an Indonesian goalkeeper being pushed out of the No.1 role at Ajax. What needs verifying is the name of the competitor, not the nature of the situation.
Over years of following the Eredivisie from Turin, I have found Dutch clubs manage the goalkeeper position on fairly conservative logic. They favour someone who has proven the ability to handle pressure inside their own specific system, rather than handing the shirt out on potential or external pressure. For Paes, that means the route back runs through training performances and cup games, not through a federation chairman's statement half a world away.

Ajax calls Paes one of its most popular players. That is a commercial asset. But popularity does not decide the starting spot. The article conflating the two is a familiar sleight of hand: terrace standing swapped for on-pitch standing.
In transfer valuation, the two run on separate tracks. A backup goalkeeper at Ajax can still sell shirts in Jakarta, but his transfer value takes direct pressure from minutes. This is the point stakeholders usually cover with commercial language. For Paes, minutes determine both the loan option and the sale option. A goalkeeper at his maturity sitting on the bench long-term can lose both choices in a single transfer window. If Ajax keeps him for commercial reasons in Southeast Asia, that is a sensible operating decision for the club but does not solve the football problem for Indonesia's national team.
Asymmetry of leverage: the most important structural point
The most important structural point in the whole story is the asymmetry of leverage. A federation chairman is publicly appealing to a foreign club about a player's minutes. The club is under no obligation to respond. No FIFA clause obliges Ajax to pick Paes. A public message can only create soft pressure, and soft pressure is usually read by coaching staffs as background noise.
In a 2026 press room full of men, I learned that the market trades even in seating posture. Years later, the principle holds: a federation chairman's public statement is information, and it is also a political act, calculated to produce an effect somewhere else, in this case with the domestic audience.
A small but notable contradiction appears inside the article itself. The same text says league commercialisation is very healthy, yet mentions a player-protection mechanism especially when clubs face financial problems. Placed side by side, the two sentences reveal a two-tier reality: a group of Super League clubs operating soundly, and a fragile club tail. The very existence of a dispute-resolution body for troubled clubs is indirect evidence that wage arrears and insolvency have not disappeared from Indonesian football.
This is not unusual in a developing league. Other ASEAN leagues went through similar phases: commercial-growth statements running alongside club dissolutions or unpaid wages. What matters is the gap between assertion and verifiable data. PSSI lists inputs, including VAR, Club Licensing, Elite Pro Academy and a dispute mechanism, but publishes no measurable outputs, such as how many clubs passed licensing, how many disputes were resolved. This is a familiar pattern: presenting the system instead of the results.
This leads to a question of priorities. A federation can both build infrastructure and manage club-level financial crisis, but the two require different kinds of capability. Building systems takes time and money. Resolving wage arrears takes enforcement power and a willingness to confront member clubs. Not every federation is ready for the second job.
Public lobbying is a sign of limits
Beneath the Indonesia-is-rising narrative, the real football value sits in the dependency layer. A federation is telling its reform story through the minutes of one player abroad, while not controlling those minutes. This is the core paradox.
Contrary to the common intuition that public intervention signals strength and care, I read it as a sign of limits. When private channels work, no public platform is needed. A chairman taking the matter public implies that his routine access to Ajax selection decisions is limited.
The choice of argument is also telling. Thohir praises Paes as a good man and believes the player will keep learning. That is praise of character, not of performance. In a debate about a starting spot, character praise is a weaker lever than data. It hints that the football case for Paes at this moment is not strong enough to be made publicly.

The best transfer contract usually starts with a phone call in which both sides say little. The fact that this meeting reached the newspapers shows it never got to that point.
The story also needs to sit in the wider industry frame. Indonesian football is running a fairly typical transmission chain for an emerging federation: build domestic infrastructure, export talent to stronger leagues, then use that talent's visibility to raise the national image and the federation brand. The weakest link in this chain is the dependency on foreign clubs. Indonesian football's perceived success increasingly rides on selection decisions in Europe that PSSI cannot control. This is structural dependency, not a temporary situation.
The accompanying reputational risk is clear. If Paes keeps sitting on the bench, the chairman's own public statement becomes a liability rather than an asset. He has tied himself to an outcome beyond his control. In sports media, this is the most underrated type of risk, because it only surfaces months later.
What to watch
The signal to watch is not the meeting, but Ajax's team sheet over the next six to eight weeks. If Paes keeps sitting out, a January loan becomes the most sensible solution for both the player and the national team. A goalkeeper needs minutes, and a federation needs a goalkeeper with minutes.
If Ajax keeps Paes for his commercial value in Southeast Asia while not playing him, PSSI will have to choose between two paths: keep lobbying publicly, or build a goalkeeping plan that does not depend on a club in the Netherlands. The second path is harder, slower and generates fewer headlines. But it is the only path that does not depend on someone else.
The Sports Summit meeting will not change Ajax's team sheet. What it changes is expectation. And expectation, when unmet, always comes back for the person who created it.
